5 Ways to Reheat Crumbl Cookies Without Overcooking Them

Nothing tastes as fulfilling as warm, milky crumbl cookies. If you have enjoyed your crumbl cookies and had leftovers, you sure have stored the rest for later. But how do you reheat crumbl cookies? You might never have guessed! This article outlines how to reheat and have them warm and fresh.

The best way to warm crumbl cookies

The ideal way to reheat your crumbl cookies is in the oven. What if you don’t have an oven and still want to enjoy your crumbl cookies warm?

Worry not, we have explored all the possible methods you can use to avoid throwing leftovers away. You will be able to warm crumbl cookies not only in the oven but also using other methods such as the grill, stove, and air fryer

In this video, you will see varieties of crumbl cookies.

How are crumbl cookies different from other cookies?

You may be wondering what makes crumbl cookies different from other cookies. With regular cookies, leftovers are a non-issue. People leave their cookies on their kitchen counter and still enjoy them the next morning.

However, when it comes to crumbl cookies, the combo of ingredients used means you should eat the cookies in one go. The fresher you eat them, the tastier. That is why this article outlines how you can warm crumbl cookies.

But you can still have your crumbl cookies chilled.

Why rewarm crumbl cookies?

Must crumbl cookies be reheated? Can’t you eat them as they are? When it comes to crumbl cookies, it depends on the ingredients. Chilled cookies can be eaten cold, while recipes like milk chocolate or banana cream taste better when warm.

But let’s be realistic, crumbl cookies are best eaten warm. Crumbl cookies are not like regular cookies, and you do not want to throw away your money. That is why you would want to keep them away (fresh) and warm them for later.

Besides, if you have more leftovers, the chances that you refrigerated them are high, and you would need to reheat them to enhance their taste.

How can you rewarm crumbl cookies using an oven?

how to reheat crumbl cookies

It is simple to reheat your crumbl cookies if you have an oven. First, ensure you preheat your oven to 350°F. When the oven is nicely heated, place a silicon mat on your baking piece and arrange your cookies on the mat.

Remember not to put them too close together or overlap, as they will stick together when they begin to warm up. Place your cookies in the oven and bake for 5-7 minutes, and there, you get to enjoy your warm, milky cookies.

You may want to take this experience higher and top it up with a scoop of ice cream. The taste is as good as freshly baked. With this delicacy, you can enjoy crumbl cookies like children do.

Rewarming crumbl cookies using a toaster oven

You can also warm crumbl cookies using a toaster oven. Start by placing your cookies on your crumbl cookies on the metal rack and not directing them to the cooking tray. The cooking tray only supplies heat to your cookies. The temperature should be about 300°F for 3-5 minutes, according to your preference. Keep checking on the cookies; pull them out If you feel they are ready.

Rewarming crumbl cookies on the stove

how to reheat crumbl cookies in microwave

Yes, you can reheat your crumble cookies on your stove! So, even without an oven or a toaster oven, you can still enjoy your leftover crumbl cookies.

To reheat, use a frying pan with a heavy bottom, so it doesn’t burn your cookies before they warm up. On moderate heat, place your pan on the stove and warm it under low heat. You can use a pinch of butter to help your cookies start heating up.

Now place your crumbl cookies on the pan without piling them. Always keep the flame low; otherwise, the butter will burn before your cookies get enough heat. This process will take you only 2-3 minutes.

Rewarming crumbl cookies using an air fryer

If you want to use your air fryer to reheat your crumbl cookies, it’s simple. Start by setting your air fryer temperature to 400°F and place your cookies in. Your cookies should be warm enough within approximately 2 minutes.

Rewarming crumbl cookies using a grill

Partially grilling can also preheat your crumbl cookies, especially if you have stored them in the freezer. It works the same way as when you are grilling.

First, set your grill temperature to 350°F and warm it a little. Then place your crumbl cookies on the grill. For effectiveness, remember not to scatter the cookies; instead, place them on one layer.

Partially cover your cookies with the lid so as not to burn them. Grill the cookies for 3 minutes, as you constantly check whether they are warm enough. When satisfied, flip over and grill the remaining side until warm enough. Remove them and enjoy!

Is it possible to reheat crumble cookies using a microwave?

how to reheat crumbl cookies microwave

You might be asking yourself whether it’s possible to reheat your crumbl cookies in the microwave. The answer is a resounding No. The temperature in the microwave is too high for crumbl cookies to survive and maintain their crumbl nature. By the time you are done, they will be soggy and would have lost their taste and appearance.

Nevertheless, if the microwave is your only option to reheat your crumbl cookies, there is a tricky way around it. Just remember to be extra careful and expect things to go south.

To heat your crumbl cookies using a microwave, you will reduce the microwave heat to up to 50% and spread out your cookies on a plate. The plate should be microwave-friendly.

Don’t pile your cookies on a plate, as this will worsen the outcome. 3-5 cookies are fine, depending on the size of each cookie. Once you place your plate of cookies in the microwave, be very smart and heat them at a 30-second cycle with breaks in between.

Remove your cookies when you are satisfied with the results. This method takes time and can be inconvenient. So, you can use it as the last option but get prepared just in case your cookies get soggy.

How to keep your crumbl cookies fresh

how to reheat crumbl cookies in oven

With the methods we mention earlier, you should never throw away your leftover crumbl cookies. But again, because of the fresh ingredients used to make crumbl cookies, it is best to eat them while still fresh.

However, this is not always the case. When this happens, how then can you keep crumbl cookies fresh for reheating them later?

Here are a few ways you can achieve that.

  •   Store your crumbl cookies in an airtight container for up to 3 days
  •   Beyond 3 days, freeze them for up to 2 months
  •   Don’t leave them in the open air as they dry up faster
  •   Thaw frozen cookies before reheating them for better results
  •   You can refrigerate chilled crumbl cookies

How to avoid overheating crumbl cookies?

When reheating crumbl cookies, it is easier to overcook them if you are not keen. For example, if you previously stored your cookies in the freezer, you want to put them on the countertop and give them enough time to thaw before reheating.

Reheating before defrosting is not such a bad idea. the challenge is that you will require more time to reheat. And in the reheating process, your cookies will start to “cook” and become less crunchy and soggier. You do not want to eat soggy crumbl cookies.


With these methods, you won’t avoid buying as many crumbl cookies as your wish. Because you now know how to reheat crumbl cookies! You can reheat them in the oven, air fryer, oven toaster on a stovetop, or grill them. Also, you can microwave your cookies in the worst-case scenario.

Leave a Comment